Finding the Right Therapist for You: A Comprehensive Guide

taking therapy at home

Why the Right Therapist Matters

Finding a therapist who makes you feel understood and cared for is one of the most important parts of seeking mental health treatment. Multiple studies supported by the American Psychological Association show that there is a strong link between the strength of the therapist-client relationship and the outcomes the client can expect from therapy. Intuitively, this makes sense—you’re not likely to share your personal thoughts, feelings, and experiences with someone you do not trust. Your comfort and security within therapy is an important part of being able to share your story and getting the help you need. Important components of an effective therapist include things like holding space for strong emotions, using feedback in ways that work for the client, and repairing ruptures in the therapist-client relationship. However, your individual needs are equally as important. This blog post aims to help you identify your wants and needs out of therapy as well as prepare you to go out and seek those things in practice.

How to Find the Right Therapist

Identifying Your Needs and Preferences

It is important to do some self-reflection before beginning therapy. Knowing what you’re hoping to get out of therapy may be helpful. For example, you may have noticed that it’s been difficult to think about anything other than your work lately. In therapy, you may want to learn how to build a stronger work-life balance. Alternatively, you may be struggling with your relationship with your parents after moving out of their house. In this case, you may identify that you’re looking to strengthen communication strategies. With these goals in mind, you can enter the therapeutic space feeling sure of your expected outcome. Additionally, you can ensure that you’re seeking out a therapist who feels comfortable engaging in this kind of work with you.

Researching Potential Therapists

Finding a therapist can be a confusing process, but here are some good starting places to help you find the best match. You may seek out recommendations from your doctor, check in with friends and family who have been to therapy, or conduct an online search. It can be valuable to look through the website of the therapy practice you’re looking into. See if the organization’s values align with your own, and if the therapist is known to treat the kinds of things you’re experiencing. Additionally, it is helpful to check on the therapist’s insurance policy to see if it matches with the insurance that is available to you.

Putting It Into Practice

Therapist

The Initial Consultation

Typically, the consultation with a therapist or a specific therapy practice happens over the phone, though some practices may have you come in for the consultation. Many practices, including Trust Mental Health, offer phone consultations for free. If you have a preference, it is typically accommodated. You may also be evaluated for some basic symptoms of anxiety, depression, or any other disorder that seems relevant to you.

During the consultation, you should feel empowered to ask some questions yourself. Some questions that may be relevant include, What is your availability? What experience do you have working with someone who has experienced [the experiences you’re looking to work through in therapy]? Do you use evidence-based treatment? How do you evaluate progress in therapy? Feel free to ask as many questions as you want. This time is meant to help you and the therapist discover the kind of connection you naturally have.

Evaluating the First Few Sessions

Within your first few sessions, evaluate your comfort with your therapist. Think about how your therapist responds to you. Do they seem to understand where you’re coming from, or does it seem like there are some things that they consistently do not get? Do you like your therapist’s communication style? Would you prefer if they were more direct? Less direct? If you notice something does not work for you, it is completely okay to bring that up during the session. You can share your thoughts with the therapist and see if they’re willing to accommodate your needs. However, if you bring up things that do not work for you and nothing changes, this may indicate that the therapeutic relationship does not work for you. Keep in mind that it takes time to build trust, so it’s wise to try out a handful of sessions before looking for a different therapist.

Recognizing Red Flags

There are several therapist red flags to watch out for, in addition to being unwilling to change certain aspects of therapy to best meet your expectations. These can include poor communication (i.e. not making cancelation policies clear, canceling a session at the last minute, etc.) or ethical concerns. Your therapist should never attempt to engage with you outside of sessions, including looking you up on social media or saying hi if you run into each other in public. These behaviors can damage the therapeutic relationship because there is a lack of respect for confidentiality.

Even if none of these major red flags show up in the therapeutic relationship, you should still feel empowered to trust your instincts. If something feels off, it is okay to seek out a different therapist. Your emotional safety is the top priority.

Making a Decision

Ultimately, the decision to stay with a therapist or try a different one is yours to make. You can weigh the pros and cons of the therapist after a few sessions and make an informed decision that works for you. For example, maybe your therapist’s office is a bit farther than you’d like (con), but you feel understood by them (pro) and they have a lot of experience helping people in your situation (pro). Weighing these options will differ from person to person. 

If you decide to switch therapists, you can talk to your current therapist about it. Let them know that they did not feel like the right fit, but you are thankful for the work you could do together, or let them know what did not work for you. The feedback could be helpful, and they may be able to recommend a different therapist.

taking decision with therapist

Conclusion

If you’re looking to find the right therapist for you, it is important to know what you’re hoping to get from therapy and to be aware of potential red flags. The consultation can be a great place to begin to evaluate the therapeutic relationship dynamic because you can share your goals and ask questions to see if this therapist will work well for you. From there, you can try out a handful of sessions and see how you work with this person. Be patient in your search.

If you’re looking to start therapy today, Trust Mental Health may be a great resource for you. We offer therapy in California. Our therapists represent a variety of cultural backgrounds and languages, ensuring the possibility of working with a therapist who speaks the same language as you and who understands your background in a nuanced way. Additionally, we do our best to get people in to see therapists as quickly as possible, so you do not have to wait long to receive the treatment you deserve. Book a free fifteen-minute consultation today.

Key Points

1. Finding a therapist who makes you feel understood and cared for is crucial for effective therapy. A strong therapist-client relationship is linked to better therapy outcomes. Essential qualities in a therapist include emotional support, effective feedback, and the ability to repair relationship issues.

2. Self-reflection on your therapy goals and preferences is key. Research potential therapists through recommendations and online searches. During initial consultations, ask questions about the therapist’s experience, treatment methods, and progress evaluation. Evaluate your comfort and the therapist’s responsiveness in the first few sessions.

3. Watch for red flags such as poor communication or ethical concerns. Trust your instincts and feel empowered to seek a different therapist if necessary. Weigh the pros and cons of your therapist after a few sessions to make an informed decision. If needed, discuss switching therapists for better alignment with your needs.


FAQs

 
  • Ask about their experience with your specific issues, their therapeutic approach, session structure, confidentiality policies, fees, and availability. Assess their communication style and openness.

  • Consider factors such as the therapist’s area of expertise, therapy style, gender, cultural background, location, availability, and whether they accept your insurance.

  • A strong therapeutic relationship is crucial for effective treatment. Feeling comfortable and understood by your therapist can significantly enhance the progress you make in therapy.